Stupid ideas department
18 July 2017
Here's a probably stupid idea: give bots the right to accept proposed changes to a software project. Can automation encourage less burnout-provoking behavior?
A set of bots could interact in interesting ways.
Regression-test-bot: If a change only adds a test, applies cleanly to both the current version and to a previous version, and the previous version passses the test, accept it, even if the test fails for the current version.
Harmless-change-bot: If a change is below a certain size, does not modify existing tests, and all tests (including any new ones) pass, accept it.
Revert-bot: If any tests are failing on the current version, and have been failing for more than a certain amount of time, revert back to a version that passes.
Would more people write regression tests for their issues if they knew that a bot would accept them? Or say that someone makes a bad change but gets it past harmless-change-bot because no existing test covers it. No lengthy argument needed. Write a regression test and let regression-test-bot and revert-bot team up to take care of the problem. In general, move contributor energy away from arguing with people and toward test writing, and reduce the size of the maintainer's to-do list.