leaving your porch light on during an air raid
Look, Mark Zuckerberg wasn’t grown in a vat with genetically engineered surveillance and fraud powers. The reason that Meta has the capacity to perpetrate so many scams in the first place is because marketers choose to pass customer data to them, and that data feeds Meta’s surveillance advertising ML system, which matches scammers to likely victims while making fraud harder to spot for regulators, researchers, and the brands whose trademarks get infringed.
The fraud problem is not just Meta’s fraud problem. Yes, Meta made a lot of criminal choices, including a choice to facilitate massive fraud from China (where regular people aren’t allowed on Meta sites and apps but companies are allowed to make ad accounts), but the underlying cause of Meta’s fraud crisis is a series of decisions made at other companies to put their own customers at risk.
Using Meta Pixel, CAPI, SDKs, and Custom Audiences, knowing that Meta will use the data to train machine learning systems to perpetrate fraud, is not just giving up customer data, it’s an attack on your customers, your neighbors, and your country.
Some countries might be out ahead on the problem. It looks like
Austria is in for a security and economic win, if the Austria’s
highest court prohibits Meta Platforms’ business model story holds
up. If people who use Meta sites and apps in Austria will be able to
turn off the personalized
advertising, that means not just a
safer online environment, but more revenue for legitimate businesses. In
the USA, though, we don’t have a law like the GDPR that Meta violated in
the EU. What we do have are other helpful laws like the California
Invasion of Privacy Act, which fraud victims here will be able to
use to protect themselves—by taking action against the firms that pass
data to Meta and put everyone at risk.
Bonus links
In other
Max Schrems news, Suddenly, this whole structure of how we
transfer data back and forth between the U.S. and Europe is collapsing
because the oversight body is gone.
Realistically, IT decision
makers are going
to have to pick a side, and the problems with adopting the Eurostack
and open source are technical gaps that are much easier for individual
IT-using organizations to work on than the big-picture political issues
are. (Related article from Brian Krebs, for anyone considering US-based
platforms as an option: Dismantling
Defenses: Trump 2.0 Cyber Year in Review)
The
Open Internet Can Still Win If Buyers and Sellers Unite Around Radical
Transparency by Kurt Donnell. If open web publishers want to
compete with the $100+ billion that the walled gardens attract (because
of aspects like clarity of environment, precision targeting and
relatively simple performance measurement), we must raise our
standards.
(Unfortunately, the adtech business operates on a time
scale of milliseconds to quarters. You’re not going to get companies to
agree to do something that’s revenue-positive on a scale of years but
revenue-negative today. The legit web advertising firms need to support
ad reform bills like the Building
Better Online Businesses Act in Vermont to be able to make a
credible commitment to cleaning up.)
Are Apple gift cards safe to redeem? By John Gruber. (Holiday warning: a gift card was tampered with in the store, and when someone redeemed it for their Apple account, the anti-fraud system locked them out of everything. If you have an Apple account with a lot of stuff on it, maybe re-gift the card or redeem it for physical accessories at an Apple Store? In California, if you spend the card down to less than $10 you can cash out the rest.)
AI
Is About to Empty Madison Avenue by Rajeev Kohli. (About to? WPP is
down from 200,000 employees to fewer than 90,000, and the top six agency
holding companies have gone from almost half of U.S. ad spend in 2019 to
28% in 2024. The AI
that’s hollowing out the advertising business
has been running for years. More: Big
Tech is squeezing advertising jobs and companies)
Ukrainians
sue US chip firms for powering Russian drones, missiles by Ashley
Belanger. Their complaints alleged that for years, Texas Instruments
(TI), AMD, and Intel have ignored public reporting, government warnings,
and shareholder pressure to do more to track final destinations of chips
and shut down shady distribution channels diverting chips to sanctioned
actors in Russia and Iran.
Sam
Altman’s Dirty DRAM Deal by Tom of Moore’s Law Is Dead. Nobody
hinted that OpenAI was about to swallow up to 40% of global DRAM
output—even on morning before it happened! Nobody saw this coming—this
is clear in the lack of reporting about the deals before they were
announced, and every MLID Source who works in DRAM manufacturing and
distribution insist this took everyone in the industry by
surprise.