encouraging first result from an AI right to know
Update: The reply from Verizon was:
You have successfully submitted a request to download information. We were not able to complete your privacy request due to a valid exemption under the CPRA or we couldn’t find any records associated with the information you provided.
I know they have me in their system, so this looks like it’s probably an error on the agent side.
Also I’m going to make sure that agentic AI
can reliably do
RtKs for me before I start trusting it with other form-filling tasks
like booking travel.
Status: The agent got part way through, but no success.
Original post:
Pretty soon after I posted an agentic AI
benchmark, already built, I got Mark Hinkle’s newsletter, How
to Actually Start Using AI Agents Today. Perfect timing—thank you,
universe! Now I
have no excuse not to test the most promising AI agents and see if they
will help with some of the complex processes that you
have to go through to do a right to know
(RtK) under CCPA or some
other state privacy law.
So I made an account on Manus and tried one of my go-to RtKs, Verizon. I like RtKing them because they have a bunch of LOL-worthy marketing insights (inferences, which under the law must be disclosed) about my family, or at least they did last time. Verizon is a good first RtK for people getting started with this exciting(ish) hobby.
This company is not too hard to RTK, but they do have some forms to get through, so hard enough to be a realistic test for AI. Here’s the transcript with my contact info redacted. tl;dr: it worked (mostly).
My first prompt was a little disappointing. I provided what I thought was the right form URL, and Manus got stuck. But I tried again. This time I supplied the privacy policy URL and told Manus to look in the California section, and it got through.
Only one error. I provided a phone number but it filled in n/a
until corrected. But as soon as I supplied the right number it did the
right thing.
The problem with RtKs compared to other software tests is that one person can only RtK the same company every so often. So I’d be really interested in seeing what happens when other people do variations on this one. Don’t feel bad about overloading Verizon with RtKs—if they can afford to pay off the former Twitter to show ads to bots then they can afford to do these.
Make a Manus account.
Prompt it with your contact info and the URL of the privacy policy to start with (don’t go down the dead end that I did) https://www.verizon.com/about/privacy/full-privacy-policy
See if it can get to the success screen, and if the RtK data shows up.
I know a lot of people are still doubtful
that AI
is making much progress in doing original work, but
solving RtK mazes isn’t really that. RtK mazes
are a class of
problems that somebody already designed, like solving
CAPTCHAs.
More: personal AI in the rugpull economy The biggest win from personal AI will, strangely enough, be in de-personalizing your personal information environment. By doing the privacy labour for you, the “agentic” AI will limit your “addressability” and reduce personalization risks.
Bonus links
The
promise that wasn’t kept by Salma Alam-Naylor. What’s becoming
clear is that the mass adoption of AI is shifting the focus away from
human-centred software solutions that provide meaningful value, and is
reducing the entire industry to just the tools at its disposal. Just
generate the code, bro. Just ship one more app, bro.
(via Re:
broken promises by Heather Buchel)
Meta
Busted Spying on Android Users In Extremely Creepy New Way, Then Lies
About It (I’m for removing the Meta apps: WhatsApp, Instagram,
Threads, Facebook before the next story like this comes along and
surprises
everybody. Related: Meta’s Failing Ad
Moderation: Health Scams Targeting EU Users | AI Forensics from AI
Forensics)
Trump’s FTC may impose merger condition that forbids advertising boycotts by Jon Brodkin. (like I said, time to sharpen your pencils, people)
Rosemary has been linked to better memory, lower anxiety and even protection from Alzheimer’s by Dipa Kamdar. (If you’re in the area you’re welcome to take a cutting. Rosemary bushes do really well around here.)
America’s
Newest Gamblers Are Playing a Dangerous Game By Hana Kiros.
Sports betting seems to be spurring a rise in gambling addiction—one
that the U.S. isn’t equipped to address.
(don’t wait for The
Algorithm to target you for deceptive ads, get protected. picking
up cheap shoes in front of a steamroller)